PennyCollector.com - The official website for elongated pennies, penny books and penny machines

Location Details:

Machine Details:

Location Name:
Address:
City:
Country:
Zip Code:
Website:
Location Phone:
Updated:
Status:
PennyCollector Machine:

Please include details about the machine and a written description of each coin.

Designs Type

Comments:	Pony Tails Candy Company was founded in 1965 as Chincoteague’s only candy superstore. For more than 50 years, we have been providing visitors and locals of Chincoteague Island fresh saltwater taffy, creamery fudge, handmade chocolates, Dolle’s caramel popcorn and a full line of gummies, licorice and novelty candies.<br> Pony Tails is also the Island’s premier destination for gifts, home décor, toys and jewelry. We pride ourselves on being family friendly – there is something for everyone, for every budget at Pony Tails!<br> Still family owned and operated since 1965, we hope you enjoy your visit to our store on “the Island” and on the Internet.<p> The machine is on the left, right inside front door. Designs cost 4 quarters and one penny. Designs were: <br> 1) Peace Sign, Heart, and a pony. <br> 2) 'Chincoteague Island Wild Ponies,', Pony centered, <br> 3) 'Chincoteague Island', Lighthouse with waves and running ponies, <br> 4) Four beach chairs next to each other each with one letters or symbol 'L, (heart) V, E,' on them <br> Reverse is 'Pony Tails Chincoteagues Sweets Superstore' <p> 7/26/25 Machine still active to the left right as you walk in. The store sign does appear to be falling off however..
	Please be specific regarding the machine location. Is it upstairs? Downstairs? By the entrance? etc...

Pony Tails Chincoteague's Sweets Superstore

Machine Locations > Virginia

7011 Maddox Blvd.
Chincoteague, VA , 23336

Phone: 7573366688

Website

Pony Tails Candy Company was founded in 1965 as Chincoteague’s only candy superstore. For more than 50 years, we have been providing visitors and locals of Chincoteague Island fresh saltwater taffy, creamery fudge, handmade chocolates, Dolle’s caramel popcorn and a full line of gummies, licorice and novelty candies.
Pony Tails is also the Island’s premier destination for gifts, home décor, toys and jewelry. We pride ourselves on being family friendly – there is something for everyone, for every budget at Pony Tails!
Still family owned and operated since 1965, we hope you enjoy your visit to our store on “the Island” and on the Internet.

The machine is on the left, right inside front door. Designs cost 4 quarters and one penny. Designs were:
1) Peace Sign, Heart, and a pony.
2) 'Chincoteague Island Wild Ponies,', Pony centered,
3) 'Chincoteague Island', Lighthouse with waves and running ponies,
4) Four beach chairs next to each other each with one letters or symbol 'L, (heart) V, E,' on them
Reverse is 'Pony Tails Chincoteagues Sweets Superstore'

7/26/25 Machine still active to the left right as you walk in. The store sign does appear to be falling off however..

Machine 1